Welcome to Trinity Buffalo!
For the best experience, please view this page on a desktop or tablet device

The Call Trinity Church of Buffalo, New York, seeks a new rector who embraces an open and spiritually inquisitive community, embodies caring and compassion, and is excited about the opportunity to support the ongoing growth of a strong and vibrant family-friendly congregation a richly textured urban setting.
In this parish profile, we invite you to meet people from a variety of spiritual and religious backgrounds, learn about our history and traditions, explore our current ministries and programs, and gain an understanding of both our strengths and the challenges we face as we look toward the future.
We hope that this profile will help our new rector understand what worship of God means to our congregation and sense our hope and anticipation for the opportunity to begin a new chapter for Trinity.
Parish Survey
Our February 2026 parish survey revealed a congregation deeply committed to both spiritual depth and authentic community. Several themes emerged clearly.


1. A Deep Commitment to Worship and Music
Parishioners consistently named meaningful worship and exceptional music as central to Trinity’s identity. Members cherish the blending of traditional Episcopal liturgy with modern, poetry, diverse musical styles, and creative expression. The music program is described as “inspiring,” “soul-stirring,” and “a gateway to the sacred.”
2. A Desire for Strong, Compassionate Pastoral Leadership
Our congregation seeks a rector who is:
● A thoughtful and engaging preacher
● Spiritually grounded and theologically curious
● Visible and accessible
● Compassionate in pastoral care
● Energetic and collaborative in leadership
Survey responses emphasized the importance of a rector who listens well, builds relationships, and empowers lay leadership rather than working alone.
3. Radical Welcome and Inclusion
Trinity’s commitment to inclusion across generations, identities, theological perspectives, and life experiences is one of our greatest strengths. Parishioners expressed a strong desire to continue deepening our welcome, especially to newcomers, young families, and those exploring their faith.
4. Intergenerational Growth
We are proud of our family-friendly environment and seek to expand formation opportunities for children, youth, and adults. Parishioners hope for creative approaches to faith formation that will nurture spiritual growth at every age.
5. Community Engagement and Social Justice
Members value Trinity’s engagement with the wider Buffalo community. There is enthusiasm for continuing and strengthening outreach ministries that address injustice, poverty, and systemic inequity. Our congregation desires leadership that can help articulate and organize our response to the needs of our city.
6. Strong Lay–Clergy Partnership
A consistent survey theme was the importance of collaboration. Trinity’s laity are gifted, capable, and eager to serve. We seek a Rector who recognizes and celebrates shared ministry, fostering transparency, communication, and mutual accountability.
Our Mission & Vision
Trinity is a metropolitan house of prayer – a community of worship and spiritual inquiry, welcoming all people. Recognizing our common brokenness, yet rejoicing in the reconciling love of God, we will:
-
Embody the diversity of the Christian faith as expressed through the Episcopal Church;
-
Nurture one another in our spiritual life;
-
Proclaim the love of God for all people in the voices of each new generation;
-
Gather the wisdom and resources of the community of faith to name and heal the wounds of injustice.
Trinity was founded in 1836 in order to include more people in the life of the church. We are steadfast in our mission of clear, inclusive invitation to people at all points along their spiritual journeys and from all places in society, especially those on the margins of society. We are a warm, dynamic community that gathers around the holy table to feed each other’s souls and encourage each other in carrying that spiritual nurture into places where it is needed outside the church.
The Trinity building is an artistic, sacred space for Buffalo, home to a progressive Christian community of radical welcome.
.
About Us


Our Worship
Our Sunday morning services offer a combination of traditional Episcopal liturgy with modern poetry and prose, and varying genres of music throughout. Trinity takes pride in our robust music program, including traditional hymns, spirituals, organ, piano, jazz, contemporary, and classical. On a weekly basis we feature guest musicians on brass, woodwind, and string instruments, adding to the experience.



Open Communion is a hallmark of Trinity’s worship and a visible expression of our radical welcome. All are welcome to receive Communion at Trinity, no matter your age, background, denominational affiliation or stage along the spiritual journey. Children, too are fully welcomed to the table.
Each week, we gather in a circle around the worship space, facing one another as we share in the holy meal as a community. Standing together in this way reminds us that the Eucharist is not only a personal encounter with God’s grace, but a communal act: a sign of reconciliation, belonging, and shared life in Christ. We are all held equally in God’s love.

Our Sunday evening service offers spirituality without all the religion. In an effort to make room for those who are searching for spirituality yet allergic to church, the service is deliberately non-Christian. Known as Trinity@7, this beloved service combines soft jazz music and candlelight with readings that are not specifically religious. This quiet service focuses on individual spirituality.



We offer a Wednesday noontime service where Holy Communion is celebrated and prayers are offered for the world. This is an informal gathering with shared leadership of the readings and prayers. In place of a sermon, the group engages in thoughtful discussion of the readings.

Thursday evenings offer 12 Steps@Trinity, a gathering that bridges Episcopal worship with the spirituality of 12‑Step recovery. Trinity’s 12‑Step community includes many who have walked the path toward liberation through the Steps, and they come together to share their experience, strength, and hope while celebrating the presence of God. Over time, this has grown into a strong, service‑oriented community shaped by unique, uplifting music provided by dedicated volunteer musicians—music that reinforces and deepens the 12‑Step message.
From Memorial Day through Labor Day, weather permitting, Trinity gathers Sunday mornings for outdoor worship in our courtyard. Surrounded by our beautifully tended garden, accompanied by the gentle bubbling of the pond, and framed by the subtle, steady rhythm of Delaware Avenue, we experience worship in a way that feels both contemplative and joyfully alive. These summer liturgies reflect the heart of, rooted in tradition yet open to creation; grounded in sacred ritual yet fully engaged with the life of the city around us. Worship outdoors deepens our sense of community, invites newcomers with ease, and reminds us that God meets us not only within stone walls but also under open skies.


Like all churches Trinity was affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. During the pandemic Trinity quickly adapted to online worship. While we all missed an opportunity to gather in person, technology created an opportunity to reach people in their homes and remain connected. We have an active online Trinity community and now consider online worship and programming an important part of our ministry. All of our worship services are livestreamed to Facebook and YouTube.
Community Partners
and Tenants
Trinity’s mission isn’t strictly worship attendance. We are proud to have roots in and throughout the City of Buffalo and look forward to expanding our reach and impact in the years ahead.
“Trinity Episcopal Church saw a need in our community and started Compass House in the 1970s. They are responsible for opening our emergency shelter for runaway and homeless youth ages 12-17 where we have since served over 16,000 youth of all gender identities. We have a Trinity representative on our Board, and the church is very supportive of all the events Compass House does. We are forever grateful for the relationship we have with Trinity!” - Lisa Freeman, Executive Director of Compass House
“Trinity Episcopal Church has been an incredible partner in supporting Creative Restorations’ mission to serve the community. Their commitment to compassion, collaboration, and opening their doors to organizations doing meaningful work truly reflects the spirit of service that strengthens neighborhoods.” - Christopher Harzynsk, Founder/President/CEO of Creative Restorations INC
For more about the partner organizations housed at Trinity and highlights of our congregation’s support of their activities last year:
-
Justice for Migrant Families is supported by Trinity volunteers, they are on the front lines of supporting our neighbors at risk of detention and deportation.
-
Center of Glass & Light raised over $160,000 to support the restoration of Trinity's "Sealing of the Servants of God" window.
-
Stained Glass Association of America (SGAA) - In addition to increasing the visibility of the importance of historic stained glass throughout Western New York, SGAA has supported the Center of Glass & Light in raising money to restore Trinity's windows. Additionally, SGAA hosted 5 window tours for other organizations.
-
Clean Air Coalition of Western New York - In addition to their regular work, they were responsible for two outside organizations choosing to rent Trinity space during the last year: Go Bike Buffalo and the WNY Land Conservancy.
-
Creative Restorations - Were able to give out 400 meals donated by Trinity members for their clients.
-
Gardens Buffalo Niagara - Trinity members joined the Jewish Federation and other Buffalo houses of worship in visiting East Side gardens and also participated as gardeners as well as garden visitors for Garden Walk Buffalo, Open Gardens, and the East Side Garden Walk.
-
Jung Center - has a monthly book study at Trinity that has included Trinity members since its inception.
In addition:
-
Our City Action Buffalo - Hosted a name change clinic attended by approximately 50 people
-
The Rainbow Room - Organizes 12 step meetings that are safe spaces for the LGBTQIA+ community
-
Buffalo Immigrant Leadership Team (BILT) - Building a strong, healthy refugee and immigrant community in and around Buffalo
-
Liberated Wellness Center - Provides intentional, holistic, and thoughtful interventions that promote healing and wellbeing, particularly for Black, Brown, Queer and other marginalized individuals and communities.

Special Events and Services
Trinity engages in many local social justice-oriented events and partnerships across the city and serves as a venue for a wide variety of cultural events, meetings, and services throughout the year.



Annual Buffalo Pride Parade
Our children at play
Our church is a popular spot to visit along the annual Allentown Art Festival route as art lovers come to view our beautiful building and grounds showcasing our historic windows.

Pets are a blessing!

"We the people" means everyone
Cinco De Mayo! Mocktails anyone?


Let's Go Buffalo!
Welcome to Bills Country.
We honor our Veterans at the annual Buffalo Bills watch party.
Our vets know how important peace is.


We love our children.
Trinity During Christmas

Silent Night, Christmas Eve Service


Not every church has sextons who are acrobats, but we do! During Advent, this is how the candle is lit prior to the morning service.

A LITTLE ANGEL

Financial Forecast
From a financial viewpoint, 2025 was a very good year for Trinity. Our income from fundraisers, weddings, rentals, and regular offerings was slightly higher ($10,000) than 2024, for a total of $511,000. But in addition to regular offerings, there were several large gifts for the Windows and general operations.
In 2025, our total operating revenue jumped to a record $764,000, while our expenses only rose by $11,000. The results for the year increased in our investment funds to $1,112,000. The highest number in at least 20 years.
2025 has also seen progress on realigning our physical assets. Our large parking lot was once a significant source of revenue, but in recent years, city parking patterns have changed, greatly reducing the revenue generated from it. Consequently, the pending sale will convert an underutilized asset into a positive social service with a significant increase to the Trinity endowment.
Our History
Trinity started in 1836, and since then quite a lot has happened. Our buildings are historic, as is our record of helping the Buffalo community outside of our doors. Trinity’s present-day community continues to contribute to, and foster, this rich legacy.
Built between 1869 and 1905, Trinity Episcopal Church is historically and architecturally a distinguished religious complex reflecting the growth of a major American city as well as the new developments in art and architecture during the era. Trinity is a local landmark listed on both the State and National Registers of Historic Places. The church complex is nationally significant as the site of a seminal program of opalescent glass and interior decoration by American master John La Farge.
As large and massive as our three big historic buildings are, it seems as if Trinity should have a steeple pointing high into the sky like Asbury Church (the current Ani DiFranco building at Delaware and Tupper). Like most things at Trinity there is a story behind this humble tower.
In 1877, unemployment among the sea of immigrants was even higher than usual because of the railroad strike. There were no public service agencies in Buffalo, so Dr. Walter Cary and Ms. Maria Love started the Trinity Cooperative Relief Society. Volunteers from Trinity Church found work for the unemployed and paid them in cash, food or clothing. One widow who had six children was taught to bake and sell her own bread and within a year she was making and delivering 1000 loaves of bread and so supporting her family. Then in 1893, a horrible economic depression swept the country. Rather than retreating from their work for fear there wouldn’t be enough money, Trinity House was established on Elk Street and the program expanded.
Trinity had become an “Establishment” congregation in Buffalo and many of its members wanted to build a grand tower to match those of local surrounding churches and a design was created. However, even with most of the money raised, Maria Love convinced congregational leaders to spend it on expanding Trinity House and the Cooperative Society instead. In 1903, Watson House was built on Babcock Street. Ms. Love initiated an entire movement among the downtown Churches that eventually divided the city into districts and each congregation took responsibility for caring for the people in need in their particular district.
It’s always been about the people at Trinity far more than a stone steeple.


Live, Work, and Play
in Buffalo
About Buffalo and Our Neighborhood:
We love our location in the City of Buffalo and being centrally located for supporting our community. Get to know the Allentown neighborhood which Trinity calls home.
We’re more than football and chicken wings (although ours are the best). There’s so much do, see, and explore in the Buffalo-Niagara region, including visiting our neighbors to the North in Southern Ontario!
*Click each image to learn more*
Buffalo is filled with so many quaint and well maintained neighborhoods.
Cost of living and real estate remains the best in the country.
Arts and Culture
Neighborhoods, Parks, Canada
Videos About Buffalo
Sports Fan? We got you!
We have a downtown arena, baseball field, and new football stadium just 20 minutes away.
Church Leadership
Staff
-
The Rev. Matthew R. Lincoln, Rector
-
Krista Seddon, Director of Ensembles; Pianist
-
Paul Cena, Organist and Choir Director
-
The Rev. Deacon Jeffrey Tooke, Curate
-
The Rev. William Roberts, Assisting Priest
-
Colleen O'Neill, Parish Administrator and Director of Children's Ministries
-
Jennifer Frey, Office Volunteer
-
Rich Mpelezos, Facility Manager
-
Willow D'Agostino, Caretaker
-
Jay Mpelezos, Caretaker
Vestry
-
JoAnne Sundell, Senior Warden
-
Timothy Lane, Junior Warden
-
Bing Sherrill, Treasurer
-
Elaine “Gretchen” Lodick, Clerk
-
Clint Brown
-
Connie Ervin
-
Barbara Hall-Griesmann
-
Jane Kearns
-
Vicky Kearns
-
Meg Knowles
-
Jess Poleon
-
Missy Stolfi
-
Cindy Stroud
Rector Search Committee
-
Jess Poleon, Co-Chair
-
Missy Stolfi, Co-Chair
-
Christian Eshelman
-
John Gillespie
-
Jane Kearns
-
Phoebe McKay
-
Teresa Maciocha
-
Bing Sherrill
-
Claudia Shoro


























